I can't put this in the sections for Minelab and White's . That's why will write it here. What do you think about all this ? It's from another forum and there is no given direct link to any Minelab's page, but maybe will appear...
I coppy without changes:
"Interesting document from Minelab comparing the E-Trac to the V3
Minelab just released a 6-page report touting the E-Trac over the V3 . . . an interesting read although in reading the specific claims and comments, some raise questions on accuracy . . . . . here's the text without the images . . . . intererested in what others think . . . . . having both detectors, they are both solid performers and each has features or capabilities the other may not match . . . . . . guess it's in the eye of the beholder when it comes to what facts are the ones that are brought up and which are downplayed . . . . .
Minelab’s E-TRAC vs White’s V3
Features & benefits that really matter!
The recent introduction of White’s V3 metal detector has people asking which detector is better, Minelab’s E-TRAC or White’s V3. Here we discuss some of the features and capabilities of both products that really matter.
To determine the best metal detector, we need to consider which of the features and capabilities of the two detectors impact user’s ability to detect, discriminate and recover desirable targets. The better of the two detectors will be capable of superior discrimination, detection depth and sensitivity to targets.Summary
: E-TRAC is the Superior DetectorDetection Technology
The E-TRAC’s Full Band Spectrum (FBS) Technology is the world’s deepest penetrating metal detecting technology, is more sensitive to small targets and extracts more information from a target giving it better discrimination capabilities. This means you’ll find more valuable targets, deeper and reject more trash.Discrimination Technology
The E-TRAC’s two dimensional Smartfind discrimination display has nearly ten times the discrimination resolution of the V3. It is able to accept or reject targets based on a combination of both ferrous and conductive properties, which the V3 cannot do. This means you have much more information to identify whether a target is treasure or trash.Coil Technology
The E-TRAC’s coil out performs the V3’s coil for quality and performance under all detecting conditions. The E-TRAC’s coil isn’t susceptible to falsing on wet salt sand, which the V3’s coil is.Graphical representation of information
The E-TRAC’s graphical display is consistent and provides the user with relevant information, which assists in identifying a target before digging. The V3’s ‘Analyze Screen’ can easily confuse users with different results from identical targets.Automatic features
The E-TRAC’s range of automatic settings ensures that the detector is set up efficiently so that it operates at an optimal sensitivity to ensure that maximum detection depth is achieved. The V3 requires the user to set the sensitivity and noise cancel manually, which is time consuming and can lead to less than optimal configuration and hence loss of detection depth.Design and ergonomics
The E-TRAC’s chassis and coil utilizes the latest materials including carbon fiber to make the detector light and strong.Detection Technology
Minelab’s E-TRAC uses Minelab’s patented ‘Full Band Spectrum’ (FBS) technology. FBS simultaneously transmits, receives and processes a spectrum of 28 frequencies from 1.5 kHz to 100 kHz. White’s V3 uses three frequencies 2.5 kHz, 7.5 kHz & 22.5 kHz and operates in the frequency domain only. When metal detecting, lower frequencies penetrate more deeply but higher frequencies are more sensitive to smaller targets. The E-TRAC’s full band of frequencies out performs the V3’s three frequencies for depth and for locating small targets. By operating across such a wide frequency range the E-TRAC can obtain more consistently accurate target information than the V3.Discrimination Technology
The ferrous and conductive properties of targets are used by metal detectors to discriminate treasure from trash. The E-TRAC’s Smartfind technology graphically displays a target’s ferrous and conductive properties. Ferrous properties are plotted on the vertical scale with a range of 1 to 35 and the conductive properties are plotted on the horizontal scale with a range of 1 to 50. Different areas of the graphical display can be easily shaded to discriminate out unwanted targets. The E-TRAC comes with ten pre-programmed patterns, which can be used straight out of the box or easily graphically edited. Additional patterns can also be created using E-TRAC’s Quickmask feature.
The V3’s graphical discrimination display uses a one dimensional horizontal graph based on Visual Discrimination Indication (VDI) numbers. This is similar to Minelab’s X-TERRA 305, which is about one third the price of the V3!
There is a vast difference in the discrimination resolution between the E-TRAC and V3. The V3 has a discrimination resolution of 191 VDI numbers. The E-TRAC’s Smartfind two dimensional display has a discrimination resolution of 1,750. The E-TRAC’s discrimination resolution is more than nine times greater than the V3’s. The E-TRAC, because of its two dimensional Smartfind display can also discriminate between targets based on a combination of both ferrous and conductive properties, which the V3 simply cannot do.Coil Technology
The E-TRAC comes supplied with a lightweight waterproof 11” double D coil complete with skid plate. The V3 comes supplied with a waterproof 10” double D coil.Graphical representation of information
The E-TRAC’s graphically displayed information consists of the two dimensional graphical Smartfind display, graphical pinpointing and depth indicator. The V3 has three screens; Active Search, Active Pinpoint and Active Analyze. The aim of any graphical display is to represent complex and useful information in a way that can be easily understood and interpreted. The V3’s Analyze Screen, whilst colorful, doesn’t give the user any additional useful information and can easily confuse users. In many instances based purely on the display the user might conclude the target is not desirable and move on, missing a valuable find.
About ten years ago Minelab considered introducing an ‘Analyze Screen’ on the first Explorer model, but concluded it gave the user no additional usable information. In fact even back then it was clear to Minelab’s engineers that displaying target information in this way was too inconsistent to be useable. This screen still exists in the Explorer, although it is hidden behind a special key sequence.Automatic features
The E-TRAC has three automatic features which include; Automatic Ground Compensation, Automatic Sensitivity and Automatic Noise Cancel.
The V3 has an automatic Ground Balance procedure, which needs to be repeated when new ground is searched. Automatic settings on a detector give the user confidence that the detector is operating efficiently and is achieving the greatest detection depth while still maintaining accurate discrimination. The V3’s manual settings for sensitivity and noise cancel can be problematic and time consuming. For example the V3’s manual noise cancel requires the transmit frequency to be offset by +/-5 increments. This requires the user to run through each offset position (eleven in total) to find the best frequency offset. This involves quite a few steps:
1. Go to the menu system
2. Change the frequency offset
3. Go back into detect mode
4. Slowly increase the sensitivity until noise effects the detector
5. Note the sensitivity level
6. Repeat steps 1 to 5 eleven times until the highest sensitivity is found where the detector isn’t affected by noise
7. Apply the best setting foundDesign and ergonomics
The E-TRAC has been precision engineered using the latest lightweight materials, including a carbon fiber shaft and molded upper assembly and control box. The shaft length is easily adjustable using quick release clamps with the cable protected inside of the shaft assembly. The V3 uses White’s standard Spectra style chassis design, which includes a display pod that is separate from the control box. As pictured below the V3’s chassis is very similar to the eighteen year old Spectra XLT." Linkback:
You are not allowed to view links.
Please Register or Login